ERE.net  
Recruiting Intelligence. Recruiting Community™

Todd Raphael's World of Talent
Who's hiring, who's not, and what else is hot
 
 
Tuesday, May 27, 2008

Fine Wines and Vodkas

posted by 
Todd Raphael (32)

MIT researchers gave a group of patients all the same placebo for pain relief, according to the latest Men's Health magazine. Some of the people were told the placebo was an expensive, brand-name medicine. Others were told it was a cheaper generic. Still, all of them were given the same empty pill.

Thirty percent more of the people who thought they were getting an expensive drug said it made them feel better.

It's a phenomenon that works any way you cut it -- if you tell people a hairstyle cost $200, they'll think it's better than if you tell them it cost $20 -- even if in blind trials, they can't tell the difference. The same goes for colleges; Clemson University charged more and people thought the higher price would mean they'd get a better education.

People will claim that more expensive vodka tastes better, but of course that's because it's more expensive .

A new study on wine shows similar results. If people are told a wine is more expensive, they'll say it's better than a cheaper wine, but $10 bottles beat out $150 in blind taste tests .

I wonder if this holds true in recruiting:
  • Do managers and recruiters sometimes think one job candidate is better than another, simply because they're earning more?
  • Do people assume that someone who went to a higher-priced, more expensive college is somehow smarter than another person who did not? Do employers value, for example, a public education at brainiac New College less than one that costs exponentially higher?
  • When we hear that one recruiting technology vendor has a more expensive product, is our first thought: "it must be better"? Is this the case with the price of job-board listings?
  • Most interesting: does taking a job that pays less lead an employer to think someone is less skilled and less valuable than if that job candidate had taken a higher-paid job? In other words, if a math major earns half as much teaching high school math than had she/he gone into private business, and then applies for a job, does a prospective employer think that $50,000 teacher is less smart than the $100,000 math major at an accounting company?


posted 5/27/2008 at 9:04 a.m. PT permalink | comments (3) | trackbacks (0) | email this posting
trackbacks

Trackback URL for this post:
http://www.ere.net/tb/6C27A520475E41378EA9CCEAA5648DF1

Listed below are links to blogs that reference Fine Wines and Vodkas:

There are currently no trackbacks for this blog posting.
comments

Neuroscience and Decision Making
posted 5/29/2008 at 7:45 a.m. PT by Joshua Letourneau

Todd, you are correct in your statement and question. Perhaps the most notorious study of all were the double-blind taste tests between Coca-Cola and Pepsi in the 80s'. In the double-blind tests, subjects were relatively split on Coke and Pepsi . . . however, when the taste test was subsequently administered non-blind, subjects chose Coke an overwhelming majority of the time.

There have been extensive neuroscience experiments on this subject, notably one a few years ago in which the same Coke-Pepsi taste test was recreated using PET scan in which they measured brain activity. The results were mind-blowing - to not come across as too much of a geek, I won't go further here . . . but highly recommend you checking this out :)



Coke and Pepsi
posted 5/29/2008 at 7:52 a.m. PT by Todd Raphael

This "advice to Brown" mentions it --
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/daniel_finkelstein/article3882856.ece

Interesting.



The power of suggestion
posted 6/5/2008 at 6:38 a.m. PT by Kevin Grossman

You're definitely onto something and it's certainly applicable to brand as well as price. The generic fast food in McDonald's wrapper experiment.



Please log in to post a comment to this blog. New users, please click here.

You are not logged in.

[log in] | [register]




about this blogger

(32)
photo of Todd Raphael
Editor-in-Chief
ERE Media

about Todd Raphael

email Todd Raphael






syndicate this blog

 





Todd Raphael's World of Talent blogroll

HRmarketer

Journal of Corporate Recruiting Leadership

MediaBistro

New Republic

Poynter

Slate

Weekly Standard




more ere blogs

3-O’Clock Coffee Break

3rd Rock

A to Z of Health Care Recruiting

Ali’s Sourcing Techniques

Ask The Recruiter

Attract, Retain, Repel -- Employment Branding 2007

Attracting Diverse Candidates

Attracting the New Workforce

Blogging outside the box

Contract Recruiting

CyberSleuthing!

DC Recruiting

E-Cruit Blog

Fresh Meat

Gen Y'd

Generational Recruiting

Hawaii Recruiting

Head Count

Hire Calling

Interviewing and Selecting the Best

Invested, innovative, brilliant: Improving the recruiting experience

JobFares

Lean Six Sigma

Martin Snyder's Passing Scene

Military Talent

On The BioPharm

Online Recruiting…Off the Record

Quest For The Best

Recruiter's Day Out

Recruiting for the Non-Recruiter

Recruiting ROI

Recruiting Techniques in China

Recruitment Rap

Recruitment Spin

Retention Secrets

Sales, Fails, and Tales

Search For G-Talents

Seattle - A Recruiter's Perspective

Second Life Recruitment

Senior Care Notes

SittingXlegged

Social Internet Recruiting

Social Media Marketing

Solutions to Your Call Reluctance Cash Drain

Talent in China

Talent Wire

The CareerXroads Annex

The Gatekeeper

The Good Search

The Honest Recruiter

The Life and Times of a Healthcare Recruiter

The New 3 R's: Recruit, Re-Develop & Retain

The Recruiter's Edge

The Switch

Todd Raphael's World of Talent

Truth Justice and the American Way of Headhunting

Video 2.0 for Recruitment

Webcruiting Techniques




NEW! Put fresh ERE content on your website, blog, or corporate intranet.

Get a free ERE badge like the one above on your website in three easy steps today.




most commented on (past 30 days)


in the entire ERE Blog Network...

Recession Proof Jobs (6 comments)

True story: Some Canadian employers already target parents (6 comments)

Recruiters Rescue the Bullied (6 comments)

When in Doubt Pick Up the Phone! (5 comments)

I'll Have My Mom Call Your People (4 comments)

Egregiously Bad Candidates, PART DUH:
And the winner is...
(4 comments)

Employees and Their Fake Doctors' Notes (2 comments)

On-Boarding Gen Y (2 comments)

Crazy economic times call for crazy candidate behavior? (2 comments)

Hunting Season - Recruit Now! (2 comments)




more posts in the recruiting blogosphere


view more...


archives

November 2008

October 2008

September 2008

August 2008

July 2008

June 2008

May 2008





   
© 2005 Electronic Recruiting Exchange, Inc. All rights reserved.
ERE home page | advertise | user agreement | about ERE