Several varieties of
Grey Poupon exist, each crafted to address one’s primal need for mustard. But
like the original
commercial, within the recruiting community there exist factions of
recruiters and recruiting pundits/experts who believe that if you don’t follow
in line to their proselytizing you are open to ridicule.
For instance, take Applicant
Tracking Systems – please! How many
are there? Rhetorical question. How many recruiters believe their choice is the
best ATS out there? Another rhetorical question. Yet the number of “best ATS”
discussions has proliferated on every recruiting forum with each discussion
becoming more heated as contrarians and purchasers of other systems proffer
their opinion on why their choice was best.
They’re all failing to cut the
mustard because each misses out on explaining how their specific processes,
budgetary constraints, IT departments, ad
naseum influenced their decision. This would constitute real information
that would be useful to the community.
So why don’t we offer said
information?
Because of the first tenet of the Poupon Principle:
There are currently no trackbacks for this blog posting.
comments
Can you clue a new reader in?
posted 7/17/2008 at 7:08 p.m. PT by Jerry Albright
Evening Steve. For a new reader such as myself - can you clue me in here? Just what are you getting at? I'm pretty sure I'm of the same philosophy - but want to make sure I'm catching your drift.
Can you spell it out? What is gnawing at you? All the though leaders? Or is it just that anyone can say anything they like about their product without having to verify it?
What is it?
Drifting towards more mustard
posted 7/18/2008 at 6:56 a.m. PT by Steven Levy
Gnawing isn't quite the right word; I'm trying to engage others in a discussion about what it's going to take to raise (or better yet "return") ERE to the entrepreneurial, all-for-one-one-for-all culture of it's early years. Let me explain using the ATS...
Here's a simple Google I did for "site:www.ere.net (ATS OR applicant.tracking.system) inurl:groups"
http://tinyurl.com/5prncm
Notice how the requests for an ATS recommendation for one's situation results in most everyone asserting that the ATS they chose is great - with so very few people asking the questioner to explain their situation - special processes, budgetary constraints, IT infrastructure, etc. Per this example, not a single ATS is true plug-and-play so individual requirements are paramount (I'm an engineer so I have some experience in the technical realm) - yet the prominent response is to assert rather than to explain how the selection was made. Without the details of the decision, it's nothing more than a paid advertisement - how is this helping the community to make more informed decision?
A corollary of the first tenet is to ask for help without explaining what has been done to date. When Maureen Sharib first started her ASK and Sourcing groups, one of the things I suggested was that she "enforce" a "rule" that if you want the community assist you in a befuddling search all you have to do is simply let the group know exactly what you've done so far and what your results have been. I'd say that's a reasonable trade-off for receiving free advice, right?
So what has happened? The bulk of people asking "I've done everything I can - posted at all the job boards - but nothing. What else can I do?"
Can these people cut the mustard as recruiters?
Recrutiers cutting the mustard
posted 7/18/2008 at 9:07 a.m. PT by Jerry Albright
I see what you mean Steve. Many so called "recruiters" really do nothing of the sort. They're internet/clerical type folks who happen to be somehow lumped in with those of us who are actually getting things done.
I'm with you. The ATS banter on ERE is one of the things that let my attention wander to greener pastures. I drop in now and again - and I'm still subscribed to a few groups. When all is said and done though it mostly shakes out to be a bunch of ATS promoters and bashers. Not really much substance so I've strayed.........
Cheers!
Please log in to post a comment to this blog. New users, please click here.
more ere blogs 3-O’Clock Coffee Break 3rd Rock A to Z of Health Care Recruiting Ali’s Sourcing Techniques Ask The Recruiter Attract, Retain, Repel -- Employment Branding 2007 Attracting Diverse Candidates Attracting the New Workforce Blogging outside the box Contract Recruiting CyberSleuthing! DC Recruiting E-Cruit Blog Fresh Meat Gen Y'd Generational Recruiting Hawaii Recruiting Head Count Hire Calling Interviewing and Selecting the Best Invested, innovative, brilliant: Improving the recruiting experience JobFares Lean Six Sigma Martin Snyder's Passing Scene Military Talent On The BioPharm Online Recruiting…Off the Record Quest For The Best Recruiter's Day Out Recruiting for the Non-Recruiter Recruiting ROI Recruiting Techniques in China Recruitment Rap Recruitment Spin Retention Secrets Sales, Fails, and Tales Search For G-Talents Seattle - A Recruiter's Perspective Second Life Recruitment Senior Care Notes SittingXlegged Social Internet Recruiting Social Media Marketing Solutions to Your Call Reluctance Cash Drain Talent in China Talent Wire The CareerXroads Annex The Gatekeeper The Good Search The Honest Recruiter The Life and Times of a Healthcare Recruiter The New 3 R's: Recruit, Re-Develop & Retain The Recruiter's Edge The Switch Todd Raphael's World of Talent Truth Justice and the American Way of Headhunting Video 2.0 for Recruitment Webcruiting Techniques
NEW! Put fresh ERE content on your website, blog, or corporate intranet.
Get a free ERE badge like the one above on your website in three easy steps today.