Receive daily articles & headlines each day in your inbox with your free ERE Daily Subscription.

Not logged in. [log in or register]

Game On! LinkedIn Fires Next Shot in War for the Career Social Graph

David Manaster
Jul 2, 2011, 12:13 am ET

Another shot has been fired in the war to own the social career networks — TechCrunch reported today that LinkedIn has cut off access to its data to both BranchOut and Monster’s BeKnown.

As we’ve reported, both services are designed to leverage Facebook’s social graph and more than 750 million users to help them find career opportunities through their friends. Until LinkedIn’s move, they had been able to use the API to give those Facebook users a shortcut in creating a resume on their own services, making them easier to set up.

As this conflict unfolds, we are going to hear a lot from each party about how they are acting in consumer’s best interests, while the other side is trampling their rights. Don’t be fooled by the rhetoric though — all three companies are simply following the money and acting for their own best interests.

LinkedIn has not yet commented publicly about this situation, and its blog doesn’t even hint that anything out of the ordinary is going on. But when it does, LinkedIn will likely claim that it is protecting its users’ privacy. Who could argue with that?

But the real motivation here is something else. LinkedIn’s rapidly growing business depends entirely on its proprietary data; there’s just no way that it is going to let other companies use its own data to compete with them. In fact, the LinkedIn API’s Terms of Use, section 1.5.n., explicitly states that companies using the API agree not to “use the APIs in an Application that competes with products or services offered” by LinkedIn, something that Monster and BranchOut were surely aware of when they built their applications.

Monster’s Vice President of Product Management Matthew Mund posted Monster’s official response to the API shutdown. In it, he says:

We are disappointed by this decision. Why? It’s not good for LinkedIn users: blocking the API effectively limits LinkedIn members’ ability to import their own profile data or invite their own connections to another environment, whether BeKnown or others.

See? Monster is doing this for the poor suffering users who just want to post their data anywhere they want.

Except that Monster’s entire business is charging for access to a closed database. In the Monster Terms of Use, the company specifically prohibits anyone who would “aggregate, copy, or duplicate in any manner any of the Monster Content or information available from any Monster Site, without express written consent from Monster.” What’s good for the LinkedIn goose is clearly not good for the Monster gander.

As for BranchOut, its public position is similar to Monster’s. As the new kids on the block, it also seems happy to be getting this kind of attention, and used its response to the TechCrunch article to promote the superiority of the Facebook audience over LinkedIn’s.

This move by LinkedIn will not greatly hurt either BranchOut or Monster’s services in any big way — importing a resume was just a convenience for their users, who can still create profiles the old-fashioned way. But its a clear sign that LinkedIn recognizes that these services are taking aim squarely at its market, and that it won’t just roll over and let them do it.

Or to quote Monster VP Eric Winegardner, “game on.”

This article is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to offer specific legal advice. You should consult your legal counsel regarding any threatened or pending litigation.

  1. Monster launches networking app – Memphis Commercial Appeal – Facebook Is Down

    [...] ERE Media [...]

  2. John Dennehy

    I’ve read through LinkedIn’s Terms and Conditions and tried to summarize them as best I can. This is a layman’s interpretation that gives, hopefully, a helpful overview:

  3. Fighting over Facebook | HREOnline's The Leader Board

    [...] so totally does not agree, writes David Manaster on the ERE site, noting that “LinkedIn has cut off access to its data to both BranchOut and Monster’s [...]

  4. BranchOut blocked from LinkedIn API – Social Barrel

    [...] (press release)Monster Responds to LinkedIn API Blocking ActionMarketWatch (press release)ERE Media -SYS-CON Media (press release) (blog)all 23 news [...]

  5. LinkedIn to Monster & BranchOut: Pay Up! -

    [...] has learned more details about LinkedIn’s July 1 decision to cut off Monster’s BeKnown and BranchOut’s API access. We’ve also obtained [...]

  6. Whose Data Is It? | HR Examiner with John Sumser

    [...] David Manaster concludes: [...]

  7. BranchOut blocked from LinkedIn API – Social Barrel | My Blog

    [...] (press release)Monster Responds to LinkedIn API Blocking ActionMarketWatch (press release)ERE Media -SYS-CON Media (press release) (blog)all 23 news [...]

  8. LinkedIn Opens Conference Amid a Changing Social World -

    [...] Monster and BranchOut both built their career networks on the Facebook platform, leveraging the enormous traffic and engagement that the site enjoys. Both sites connected with LinkedIn as well. Even as it climbed past 2 million users, BranchOut managed to avoid problems with LinkedIn. Monster’s BeKnown, however, triggered a prompt rebuke from LinkedIn, which shut out both sites and some other, minor players. [...]

Post a comment

Please log in to post a comment.

Note: You need to sign up for an account on our new commenting system if you haven't already done so — even if you have an existing ERE account. Find out why »

Login Information